Understanding Liability in Dog Bite Cases: A Complete Guide
Share:
Dogs are beloved members of millions of households, but when a bite occurs, the aftermath can be overwhelming. Victims may face painful injuries, infection risks, permanent scarring, and mounting medical expenses. Naturally, one of the first questions people ask is: Who’s legally responsible for the bite?
While the dog’s owner is usually the first party held accountable, the reality is more complex. Liability in dog bite cases can extend to landlords, caretakers, or even businesses, depending on the circumstances. Let’s walk through how liability works and what victims need to know.
Dog Owner Responsibility: The Law Starts Here
In most cases, responsibility begins with the dog’s owner. States like Florida and Georgia follow what’s called a strict liability rule. This means an owner can be held liable for injuries caused by their dog, even if the dog had never bitten anyone before or seemed perfectly friendly in the past.
Put simply: if the bite happened, the owner is on the hook. The law doesn’t require a long history of aggression or multiple prior incidents. As long as the victim was lawfully on the property or in a public place, strict liability generally applies.
For example, imagine a delivery driver dropping off a package who gets bitten by a dog when the homeowner opens the door. Even if the dog had no history of aggression, the owner is typically responsible.
Fact: According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), 4.5 million dog bites occur in the U.S. every year, and nearly one in five require medical attention. That’s a lot of responsibility resting on dog owners’ shoulders.
When Landlords or Property Owners Are Liable
What if the dog doesn’t belong to the property owner? In certain situations, landlords or property managers can share liability. Courts often consider whether the landlord knew a tenant’s dog posed a danger or failed to correct unsafe conditions that allowed an attack to happen.
Example: If a landlord knows a tenant owns a dog that has bitten people before but takes no action, they may be held accountable if the dog strikes again. Likewise, if a broken gate or deteriorating fence allows a dog to escape and attack someone, the property owner could share responsibility.
The principle is simple: when a property owner ignores obvious risks, they may bear part of the legal consequences.
Other Potentially Liable Parties
Dog bite liability isn’t always limited to owners and landlords. Depending on the circumstances, other parties may also be drawn into a case.
If a dog is in the care of a sitter, groomer, or walker at the time of the attack, that caretaker may be held responsible. Businesses like pet stores, boarding kennels, or veterinary offices could also face liability if their negligence allowed the bite to occur. Even parents of minors who own dogs can be held accountable for their child’s pet.
The bottom line: liability follows who had control and responsibility for the dog when the bite happened.
How Victims Prove Liability
To succeed in a dog bite claim, victims need solid evidence. Medical records are crucial because they link the injury directly to the bite. Photos of wounds and the location where the attack happened help establish what occurred. Witness statements can back up the victim’s account, and official reports from police or animal control can confirm whether the dog had a history of aggression.
One of the most important steps victims can take is to report the incident to local authorities immediately. This creates an official record and may uncover prior complaints about the same dog, strengthening the case.
Pro Tip: Always report a dog bite to animal control or local authorities. This not only documents the attack but may uncover a history of aggression.
The Damages Victims Can Recover
Dog bite cases aren’t just about physical injuries—they often leave lasting emotional scars as well. Victims may be entitled to compensation for their medical bills, including emergency treatment, reconstructive surgery, and even therapy for post-traumatic stress. Lost wages may also be recoverable if the injury keeps a victim from working.
Pain and suffering damages recognize the physical pain and emotional toll, while additional compensation may be awarded in cases involving permanent scarring, disfigurement, or disability.
Cost Insight: The Insurance Information Institute reports that in 2022, the average dog bite claim in the U.S. exceeded $64,000—a figure that reflects the seriousness and long-term costs of these injuries.
How Dog Owners and Insurers Defend Themselves
Of course, owners and their insurers don’t always accept responsibility without a fight. Common defenses include claiming that the victim provoked the dog, that the victim was trespassing, or that the victim assumed the risk—such as a professional trainer knowingly working with an aggressive animal.
In Florida and Georgia, comparative negligence laws also apply. That means if a victim is found partly at fault—for example, by ignoring a “Beware of Dog” sign—any compensation they receive could be reduced proportionally.
Why Legal Help Makes the Difference
While dog bite cases may seem simple at first glance, they can quickly become complex. Owners, landlords, businesses, and insurers often point fingers at each other, making it difficult for victims to know who’s truly responsible.
This is where an experienced dog bite attorney comes in. A lawyer can investigate the case, determine liability, gather and preserve evidence, and fight back against insurance company tactics designed to minimize payouts. Most importantly, they can ensure victims pursue the full compensation they need to recover.
Final Thoughts
Dog bites aren’t just painful—they can be life-changing. Fortunately, liability laws are designed to protect victims and hold negligent parties accountable, whether that’s an owner, a landlord, or another caretaker.
At DuFault Law, we represent dog bite victims across Florida and Georgia. We know how to cut through the excuses, prove liability, and fight for the compensation victims deserve.
Bitten by a Dog? Don’t Wait to Protect Your Rights.
Dog bites can cause serious injuries and life-changing trauma. In Florida and Georgia, owners are often held strictly liable—but landlords, caretakers, or businesses may also share responsibility. Proving liability and securing fair compensation requires experienced legal guidance.
At DuFault Law, we fight for victims of dog bites across Florida and Georgia. From gathering evidence to negotiating with insurance companies, we work to hold negligent parties accountable and secure maximum recovery for our clients.
- Call us at (239) 422-6400
- Email us at contact@dufaultlaw.com
- Or Visit our Contact Page to schedule a consultation
Comments are closed